The approach outlined to choose a start up job in this article is scientific and thoroughly professional. In my opinion however scientific and professional you may be in your approach to choosing a job, there is always a intuitive factor associated with the choice of job. When you make a spread sheet analysis of all the offers, you may still feel that a particular offer is "the offer for you" even though it may not be so good as compared to others. What will you do at this moment? will you listen to your brain or listen to your heart?
In my opinion you should listen to your heart and take up the one to which you feel close. You will do much better in the long run and develop into a much better professional and human being. Dr. Venkatesh